Talk Me Out Of It: The daily driver hunt

I need a daily driver. Can a 12-year-old BMW 550i for under $20,000 pique my interest, or should I look elsewhere?

TMOOI-banner

Seems like 75% of you want a V-12, and despite the Alpina’s appeal, I agree with you. This week, I need some genuine help because I must find a daily driver. And I do love making bad decisions. Would this BMW 550i qualify as a terrible one?

The 2011 BMW 550i

bmw-550i
The color combo and lack of M Sport sadden me. Photo: Carvana

See the BMW 550i listing here

The used market is a bit of a mess right now. Nothing is cheap, and I’m not going to pay $30,000 for a used 228i. Sorry.

It’s common belief that a decent daily must be the opposite of your “special” car, and that means boring. But does it really need to be? This 550i from Carvana (we’ll talk about them in a minute) might just make a case:

  • $15,990
  • 78,290 miles
  • Clean CarFax
  • It’s just a totally gross color combination – beige on tan? Wood trim? Big yuck.
  • But it does have the glorious N63. How ’bout 400 horses and 450 lb-ft or torque
  • A few dings in the body, nothing major
  • The interior is not great, but I have a feeling some steam and an AMMO bath would bring it back to life.
  • A hilariously outdated iDrive system. But we can update the module to accept Apple CarPlay.
  • No M Sport, or anything resembling an M badge lives here.
  • Ugly tint across the windshield
bmw-550i-m-sport
They look so much better with M Sport bumpers.

Now, Carvana. They offer a free 100-day warranty after purchase (meh), but also allow you to add a warranty at purchase. This on a 12-year-old car with a V-8 known to have more problems than your relationship after a Vegas trip with da’ boys. One thing is certain: ownership would be eventful.

But is there a better way?

The 2014 BMW 335i Gran Turismo

bmw-335i
The GT – it’s not pretty. Photo: Carvana

See the 335i listing here

BMW, you gotta love ’em..

“You don’t like ze wagons? What if we make a regular 3 Series ugly, and make it less useful than ze wagon?”

Big surprise that the GT did not sell well. But you know what? Since we never got a 335i F30 wagon here, this car is about as close as it gets, and it is more practical than the sedan, so…

  • $20,990
  • 62,917 miles
  • Jet Black? Black Sapphire? It’ll be a surprise
  • Oyster inside again – why would you order a light interior and not clean it, ever?
  • Pre-LCI, so N55, no cool LED lights
  • An iDrive not quite as ancient as the BMW 550i, but still old
  • Clean CarFax
bmw-335i
I racked up a combined 200,000 miles on two F30s. Dare I grab a third?

Now, if you asked me to pick the two worst engines BMW made, reliability-wise, these are probably up there. But they are cheap, and I can drive them right to TySpeed, where no doubt they will look at me with disdain as I pull in the bay. And I didn’t exactly make a clean getaway with my previous N55 experience.

400 horses for less than $20k is hard to pass up though.

What do you think? Should I take one home, or find something better?

Want your car reviewed?

If you live in the tri-state area and want me to check it out, send me an email! 

Support the cause

Commissions may be received for product links on this site. Help out if you can.

I use Nikon camera bodies and lenses, a Westcott Ice Light 2, Manfrotto tripod, B + W filters and an iMac Pro to make the art you see here.

Follow along on Instagram @machineswithsouls

One thought on “Talk Me Out Of It: The daily driver hunt

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *